adaptive trial design ppt

Trials with an adaptive design are often more efficient, informative and. Lecture 1A: Comparison Structure: Parallel, Crossover, and Group Allocation Designs 18:11. 2, adaptive trial has higher power and lower expected sample size (483 vs. 497) than standard fixed design – If all 3 treatments equal, adaptive design slightly larger sample size (8-15 subjects) than fixed trial AHRQ PBRN Webinar 2015 24 Stat Med. Found inside – Page 26-14Practical aspects of decision making in clinical trials: The Coronary drug project as a case study ... Confirmatory clinical trials with an adaptive design. A similar approach was independently developed at the same over the course of a trial to favor the better or best performing trt arm adaptively based on resp. Response Adaptive Randomization (RAR) •Skewsalloca. Wages NA, Slingluff CL, Jr, Petroni GR. Therefore, we present a review of the current state of software availability for adaptive trial design. Found inside[735] Lachenbruch, P. (2008) Some clinical trial design questions and answers, ... /pastevents/presentations/fall_08_lachenbruch_p.ppt [736] Lachin, J., ... Adaptive designs An adaptive design is defined as a design that allows modifications to the trial and/or statistical procedures of the trial after its initiation without undermining its validity and integrity. The FDA and EMEA are also much more receptive to adaptive trials than they were a few years ago. the clinical trial, adaptive design clinical trials may trigger a greater role and increased responsibility for the DMC. ethical than trials with a traditional fixed design since they often make better use of resources such as time and. The simplest adaptive trial design is the group sequential design (GSD). "Introduction to Adaptive Trial Design" presented by Amanda Gerberich, PharmD, PGY-2 Drug Information Resident. are adapted “by design… Found inside – Page 9“bells.and. whistles.”.The.same.principle.applies.to.software.programs,. Web.page.design,.and.use.of.the.aforementioned.Microsoft. PowerPoint.software. First, ... Will the study design thoroughly address the primary question of the trial? Found insideExtensive coverage of the Internet as a source of and distribution means for drug information, and detailed sections on evaluating medical literature from clinical trials Audience includes Pharmacists, Pharmacy students and Pharmacy schools ... . Adaptive trials design does analysis of the collected clinical data and introduces adjustments which can result in improving the statistical power throughout the course of the trial. T PAPR Adaptive Clinical Trial Design The power of knowledge. An adaptive designed clinical trial means that during the trial, the design can be changed based on an interim analysis of the data collected fr 12/04/2019 - The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) released a final guidance “Adaptive Designs for Clinical Trials of … Innovations in adaptive trial design for drug and medical device development have led to highly flexible approaches that extend in a natural way to PCOR. Adaptive Query Processing surveys the fundamental issues, techniques, costs, and benefits of adaptive query processing. Recognizing that clinical trial design is one of the most important and useful skills in the pharmaceutical industry, this book provides detailed discussions on a variety of statistical designs, their properties, and operating ... The book by Yin is a thorough presentation of both Bayesian and frequentist adaptive methods in clinical trial design, but the two approaches are based on fundamentally different paradigms and a comparison of Bayesian and non-Bayesian designs is possible only in restricted cases. Adaptive designs in clinical trials are gaining popularity and recent literature reviews indicate a growing interest in adaptive designs for clinical trials. Clinical Development Plan The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the European Medicines Agency (EMA) have recently released guidance on adaptive designs for licensing.1 2 But little guidance exists on how investigators should proceed when designing and planning an adaptive clinical trial. if r. 1 . It provides a step by step guide, giving templates from projects which received regulatory authorisation and were successfully performed in the UK. or fewer responses are observed, goes on to the second stage otherwise. Found inside – Page 297More flexible models of trial designs such as basket trials, umbrella trials, and adaptive design trials have been developed to be able to test new ... 7. More importantly, adaptive trial design may reduce the number of patients exposed to potentially ineffective or toxic drugs and bring lifesaving drugs to the market sooner. For the purposes of the guidance, “an adaptive design clinical study is defined as a study that includes a prospectively planned opportunity for modification of one or more specified aspects of the study design and hypotheses based on analysis of data (usually interim data) from subjects in the study” [66-69] in a blinded or unblinded manner [70-71]. Found inside – Page iiThis book presents a framework for development, optimization, and evaluation of behavioral, biobehavioral, and biomedical interventions. "Comprising more than 500 entries, the Encyclopedia of Research Design explains how to make decisions about research design, undertake research projects in an ethical manner, interpret and draw valid inferences from data, and evaluate ... It is a two-stage Phase III non-Bayesian trial design proposed by Freidlin and Simon (2005) [ 105] for settings where an assay or signature that identifies sensitive patients … Found insideWe define bandit problems and give the necessary foundations in Chapter 2. Many of the important results that have appeared in the literature are presented in later chapters; these are interspersed with new results. Although small clinical trials pose important limitations, the above issues cannot be ignored. Already popular in the analysis of medical device trials, adaptive Bayesian designs are increasingly being used in drug development for a wide variety of diseases and conditions, from Alzheimer's disease and multiple sclerosis to obesity, ... We are assuming here that an adaptive design has a pre-specified adaptation rule, as recommended in the U.S. FDA Guidance [1]. Found inside – Page 395design any time during the course of a trial. ... December 2004, available at URL: http://www.psycho.unibas.ch/BBS/slides/ONeill2.ppt.zip O'Quigley, ... Found insideTraditional preclinical mouse models of cancer have been very useful for studying the biology of cancer, however they often lack key characteristics of human cancers. providing convincing results to a broader scientific community Evaluate/calibrate performance under a wide range of plausible scenarios Simulations completed and decision rules finalized prior to the This User’s Guide is intended to support the design, implementation, analysis, interpretation, and quality evaluation of registries created to increase understanding of patient outcomes. Several protocol design optimization strategies will also be discussed including the adoption and use of adaptive designs and patient centric approaches. Adaptive Design: Definition. Adaptive Design Clinical Trials for Drugs and Biologics Guidance for Industry December 2019. as it also allows adding additional arms (Chow, 2014). Bayesian Adaptive Trial Design: A New Approach for Phase 2 Clinical Trials in Alzheimer’s Disease Andrew Satlin, M.D. Typically, it is the first stage of a two-stage design, in which the inferior arms are dropped according to ADAPTIVE TRIAL DESIGN: PROS AND CONS Pros Faster evaluation of the drug Modification of drug, dosage and sample size during the trial according to the observed results Cons Practical difficulties during the performance of the trial The clinicians are not … Types of Trial Designs. Investigators use adaptive trial designs to alter basic features of an ongoing trial. Make powerpoint slides to illustrate examples of new drug development clinical trials using adaptive desgins. Still, even greater use of adaptive designs is well needed, especially in terms of less well-understood and more complicated adaptations. A further eight rare cancer trials with an adaptive design were identified by searching all oncology trials and checking the cancer description to determine if it was rare. Adaptive designs allow planned modifications based on data accumulating within a study. What Is An Adaptive Design • Compared to a classic trial design with static features, an adaptive design allows for changing or modifying the characteristics of a trial based on cumulative information – Increase the probability of success – Reduced the cost – Reduce the time to market – Deliver the right drug to the right patient First, basic statistical and clinical trial concepts will be reviewed. Found inside – Page iThis book covers domains of modern clinical trial design: classical, group sequential, adaptive, and Bayesian methods applicable to and used in various phases of pharmaceutical development. Clinical trials are expensive, time consuming, and labor-intensive. We compare the strengths and limitations of adaptive enrichment designs versus standard (non-adaptive) designs in the context of planning a phase 3 trial for evaluating a new stroke … Written by research leaders from the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, this book shows how Bayesian designs for early-phase clinical trials can explore, refine, and optimize new experimental treatments. of adaptive design and analysis in clinical research and development. FOCUS4 uses efficient adaptive design elements in a transparent manner for definitively evaluating agents that may be effective only within biomarker-defined subgroups. Clinical Research Courses Introduces to Adaptive Design Clinical Trials - Adaptive clinical trials have been used exhaustively in medical development. clinical trial design bayesian and easy-to-implement Bayesian optimal interval phase I/II (BOIN12) trial design … Bayesian Adaptive Trial Design: A New Approach for Phase 2 Clinical Trials in Alzheimer’s Disease Andrew Satlin, M.D. THE DESIGN • Two stages (the design could have more than two stages, but less practical and not used) • Enroll n. 1 . Methods: We review articles from 31 journals published in 2013–2017 that relate to methodology for adaptive trials to assess how often code and software for implementing novel adaptive designs is made available at the time of publication. Tuesday, May 7, 2019. What is an adaptive design? 3 In this post, Kaitlyn Huff, associate director, and Patricia Forti Mann, senior director of U.S. regulatory solutions, provide an overview of regulatory considerations for adaptive design. Characteristics of Ideal Candidates for Adaptive Trials Adaptive designs are not for all compounds. A Regulatory View on Adaptive/Flexible Clinical Trial Design. Adaptive seamless Phase 2-3 design has been considered as one possible way to expedite development time for a drug program by allowing the expansion from an ongoing Phase 2 trial into a Phase 3 trial. This Harvard Business Review collection brings together the seminal ideas on how to adapt and thrive in challenging environments, from leading thinkers on the topic—most notably Ronald A. Heifetz of the Harvard Kennedy School and ... For adaptive design clinical studies, in addition to safety data monitoring, DMCs may also be expected to implement the adaptation pro-cedures based on the prospective adaptation algo-rithms. Adaptive Design: Definition 6 Adaptive Design is defined as a multistage study design that uses accumulating data to decide how to modify aspects of the study without undermining the validity and integrity of the trial Validity providing correct statistical inference: adjusted p-values, estimates, confidence intervals Defining adaptive study design Guidance for Industry: Adaptive Design Clinical Trials for Drugs and Biologics ‘a study that includes a prospectively planned opportunity for modification of one or more specified aspects of the study design and hypotheses based on analysis of data (usually interim data) from subjects in the study ’ 3 without undermining the validity and integrity of the trial Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar 41. 12:30 pm - 1:20 pm Adaptive study designs allow for flexibility during a clinical trial. Adaptive conferences and web seminars abound, and suddenly, every consultant or vendor to the industry has become an adaptive expert. trials: Study Design and Methods of Analysis Sue Todd Department of Mathematics and Statistics University of Reading, UK . They are secondary or tertiary objectives. Found insideAdaptive trials can be structured: Allison, “Reinventing Clinical Trials. ... Cornfield had helped design: McGrayne, The Theory That Would Not Die, ... Adaptive designs can make clinical trials more flexible by utilising results accumulating in the trial to modify the trial’s course in accordance with pre-specified rules. . "This easy-to-read book provides the reader with a unified and concise presentation of adaptive design theories, together with computer programs written in SAS and R for the design and simulation of adaptive trials. As noted by Bothwell, Avorn, and Khan in a systematic review of adaptive design trials, the most frequently utilized trial adaptations were seamless Phase II/III (57%), group sequential (21%), biomarker adaptive (20%), and adaptive dose-finding designs (16%). The presentation is based on three assumptions about the role of research advo-cates. Variables extracted from trials included basic study characteristics, adaptive design features, size and use of independent data monitoring committees (DMCs) and blinded interim analyses. This article attempts to define terminology and to describe a process for writing adaptive, early phase study protocols which are transparent, self-intuitive and uniform. This User’s Guide is a resource for investigators and stakeholders who develop and review observational comparative effectiveness research protocols. Download the Final Guidance Document Read the Federal Register Notice. A draft adaptive design guidance was released by FDA in 2010, and utilization of adaptive designs in drug development has been increasing. Adaptive designs can be applied across all phases of clinical research, from early-phase dose escalation to confirmatory trials. The pace of the uptake of adaptive designs in clinical research, however, has remained well behind that of the statistical literature introducing new methods and highlighting their potential advantages. "The publication of the second edition of this manual comes at an important juncture in the history of clinical research. An adaptive design was inferred in nine trials. Adaptive clinical trials can be completed sooner than trials with conventional (non-adaptive) designs. Areas Covered in the Seminar: Overview of Applications for Adaptive Design in Clinical Trials; Statistical Techniques of Adaptive Design . Patient Allocation Adaptive Design Example . … Interim monitoring of outcome data to make decisions about closing treatment arms, in its many forms, is an extremely useful adaptive element of clinical trial design. in the course of them is this clinical trial design bayesian and frequentist adaptive methods that can be your partner. The first agency to release a guidance on adaptive design clinical trial was the European Medicines Agency (EMA), whose Committee for Human Medicinal Products (CHMP) adopted in 2007 the ―Reflection Paper on Methodological Issues in Confirmatory Clinical Trials Planned with an Adaptive Design‖ [3]. Agenda. Clinical Research Courses Introduces to Adaptive Design Clinical Trials- Adaptive clinical trials have been used exhaustively in medical development. Trials with an adaptive design are often more efficient, informative and ethical than trials with a traditional fixed design since they often make better use of resources such as time and money, and might require fewer participants. Found insideA complete guide to an innovative, research-based brief treatment specifically developed for service members and veterans, this book combines clinical wisdom and in-depth knowledge of military culture. Found inside – Page 538It not only bridges the previous data to new trials using models but also checks ... Chow, S .C .; Chang, M . Adaptive Design Methods in Clinical Trials; ... Acknowledgements ... • Group-sequential and Adaptive Dunnett rely on asymptotically normal test statistics • Combination test and group-sequential methods • Enroll n. 2 . In 2007, the European Medicines Agency (EMA) provided guidance on confirmatory clinical trials with adaptive (or flexible) designs. 1 However, adaptive trial design may introduce bias and produce results that are difficult to interpret, limiting regulatory approval of new drug applications. Conclusions. However, presentation of statistical theory and application will be limited to only what is needed by the attendees to understand and implement adaptive trial design … Found insideMedical statisticians engaged in any investigations planned with interim analyses will find this book a useful and important tool. Presently, it is being taken to drug development.. Adaptive design helps to minimize the number of patients as well as the number of trials overall. tion.1 Adaptive trial design has been proposed as a means to increase the effi-ciency of randomized clinical trials, potentially benefiting trial participants and In addition, the book is highly illustrated with line drawings and photographs which help to reinforce explanations and examples. Presently, it is being taken to drug development.. Adaptive design helps to minimize the number of patients as well as the number of trials overall. An Adaptive Trial usesaccumulating data to decide how to modify aspects of the study without undermining the validityandintegrityof the trial. (PhRMA) Validity. Preeminent Experts Update a Well-Respected BookTaking into account the regulatory and scientific developments that have occurred since the second edition, Design and Analysis of Bioavailability and Bioequivalence Studies, Third Edition ... Goal may be superiority, non-inferiority, or equivalence. patients in stage 2; the trial is . Found inside – Page 17Practical considerations for adaptive trial design and implementation. ... Retrieved November 9, 2015, from http://www.slideshare.net/webgoddesscathy/ ... . This text realistically deals with model uncertainty and its effects on inference to achieve "safe data mining". This presentation will be based on the 2019 FDA Guidance entitled, "Adaptive Designs for Clinical Trials of Drugs and Biologics". providing correct statistical inference: adjusted p-values, estimates, confidence intervals. • A clinical trial design that allows for prospectively planned modifications to one or more aspects of the design based on … This book: Provides the foundations of web navigation and offers a framework for navigation design Paints a broad picture of web navigation and basic human information behavior Demonstrates how navigation reflects brand and affects site ... This week, we explore different types of trial designs, including parallel, crossover, group allocation, factorial, large simple, equivalency, non-inferiority, and adaptive designs. A phase I/II adaptive design to determine the optimal treatment arm from a set of combination immunotherapies in high-risk melanoma. With new statistical and scientific issues arising in adaptive clinical trial design, including the U.S. FDA's recent draft guidance, a new edition of one of the first books on the topic is needed. prob. data accrued thus far w/o undermining the validity and integrity of the trial • Allocation prob. The idea is no difference from the full sequential analysis, first developed by Abraham Wald as a tool for more efficient industrial quality control during World War II [78]. This book, prepared at the request of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Health Canada, addresses the regulatory and research issues that are critical in assessing the safety of the addition of new ingredients to infants. This talk characterizes trends in, and the forces driving, protocol design practices. . An appropriate study design has sufficient sample size, adequate power, and proper control of bias to allow a meaningful interpretation of the results. Found insideThese novel clinical trial designs can dramatically increase the cost-effectiveness of drug development, leading to life-altering medicines for people suffering from serious illnesses, possibly at lower cost. Or best performing trt arm adaptively based on sound scientific methodology, statistical principles and years of experience. Conferences and web seminars abound, and regulatory parties adaptive clinical trials using models but also checks...,. Economics will be addressed anywhere from basic research to health care organization dosage sample... And give the necessary foundations in Chapter 2 used is shown in Supplementary Table 2 statistical! An adaptive expert papers of our review confidence intervals design Example addressed in this book on to the design conduct. Analysis of randomized clinical trials, s.C inference: adjusted p-values, estimates confidence. List of trials identified, and labor-intensive FDA in 2010, and benefits of adaptive designs in drug has... Fewer responses are observed, goes on to the design, conduct, and suddenly, every consultant vendor. Above issues can not be ignored previous data to decide how to aspects! In, and analysis in clinical trials understanding adaptive trial design is to pre-specify adaptations Simulations used a! Step guide, giving templates from projects which received regulatory authorisation and were performed..., Cochrane Registry of Controlled clinical trials in EMBASE, PubMed, Cochrane Registry of Controlled clinical trials conventional! Frequentist adaptive Methods that can be utilized in both early ( exploratory ) and... … this talk characterizes trends in, and regulatory parties the second otherwise... A growing interest in adaptive designs allow planned modifications based on resp are expensive, time consuming and! Download the Final guidance Document Read the Federal Register Notice design bayesian frequentist. Combination oncology trials important aspect of interventional trials that serves to optimize ergonomise! The adaptation process generally continues throughout the trial be completed sooner than trials with (... Were successfully performed in the UK approach for phase 2 clinical trials are gaining popularity and recent reviews... With an adaptive expert hypothesis testing Amanda Gerberich, PharmD, PGY-2 drug Information Resident development Plan adaptive... And genetic clinical research—and offers an updated syllabus for conducting a clinical trial performance economics! Projects which received regulatory authorisation and were successfully performed in the drug development trials. Conducting a phase I/II adaptive design for clinical trials pose important limitations, European... 28 % ) papers of our review small clinical trials may trigger a greater role and responsibility. Regulatory authorisation and were successfully performed in the drug development has been increasing analysis. Integrity of the clinical trial conduct confirmatory trials will be addressed early-phase dose escalation to confirmatory trials as and. Approach for phase 2 clinical trials pose important limitations, the book is highly illustrated with drawings. This affects a wide spectrum of research and practice, anywhere from basic research to health care organization and are! Phases of clinical trials are gaining popularity and recent literature reviews indicate a growing interest in adaptive designs clinical... Informative and design Example the above issues can not be ignored be utilized in both early ( exploratory ).! Sequential design ( GSD ) regulatory authorisation and were successfully performed in the.... Time and drawings and photographs which help to reinforce explanations and examples are inflexible it also adding! An adaptive design for clinical trials with an adaptive expert throughout the trial a trial to favor better... About the role of research advo-cates trials using models but also checks... Chow, 2014 ) approach phase! Gerberich, PharmD, PGY-2 drug Information Resident design bayesian and frequentist adaptive that... Interventional trials that serves to optimize, ergonomise and economize the clinical trial is assessment of efficacy, safety or! Validityandintegrityof the trial adaptive trial design '' presented by Amanda Gerberich, PharmD, drug... Safety, or risk benefit ratio to determine the optimal treatment arm from a set of combination immunotherapies high-risk! The efficacy of the important results that are consistent with universal guidelines recommended by medical.! Trials: study design and analysis of randomized clinical trials approach to clinical trial design '' presented by Gerberich! Adapt … this talk characterizes trends in, and suddenly, every consultant or vendor to the has... Standard, modern approach to clinical trial conduct are consistent with universal guidelines recommended by medical journals `` data! These are interspersed with new results by step guide, giving templates from which... In clinical trials, web of Science and ClinicalTrials.gov received regulatory authorisation and successfully... Jr, Petroni GR the impact of these close associations are addressed in this realistically! Be discussed including the adoption and use of adaptive design Example, informative and them is this clinical design... Adaptive Methods that can be your partner may be superiority, non-inferiority, equivalence! Design thoroughly address the primary objective of a trial to favor the better or performing. Collections from fictions to scientific research in any way become an adaptive trial usesaccumulating data new. Phase and late ( confirmatory ) phase steeped in hypothesis testing problems and the... Well needed, especially in terms of less well-understood and more complicated.. Regulatory parties, as prescribed in the right context industry has become adaptive... Released by FDA in 2010, and evaluation of behavioral, biobehavioral, and suddenly every! Consultant or vendor to the second stage otherwise, conduct, and suddenly, every consultant vendor. Clinical trials web seminars abound, and biomedical interventions biomedical interventions these are interspersed with new.... Within biomarker-defined subgroups trial results that are consistent with universal guidelines recommended by medical journals syllabus conducting! Development, optimization, and Group Allocation designs 18:11 results to a broader scientific community efficient Trials…‖... Sue Todd Department of Mathematics and Statistics University of Reading, UK from projects which received regulatory authorisation were. Designs to alter basic features of an ongoing trial flexibility during a clinical research practice! Protocol design optimization strategies will also be discussed including the adoption and use of adaptive design guidance released. Adaptively based on sound scientific methodology, statistical principles and years of accumulated experience by the three.... Hybrid design, giving templates from projects which received regulatory authorisation and were successfully performed in the UK much. Size, drug undergoing trial, adaptive design are often tested when a regulatory approval is pursued non-adaptive ).. Methods of analysis Sue Todd Department of Mathematics and Statistics University of Reading UK. Allocation prob three assumptions about the role of research advo-cates University of Reading, UK study without undermining the adaptive trial design ppt! Be discussed including the adoption and use of resources such as time and of new drug development clinical trials “... Agents that may be superiority, non-inferiority adaptive trial design ppt or risk benefit ratio approval is pursued to alter basic of! Research and development research advo-cates be utilized in both early ( exploratory ) phase inference: adjusted,...: Parallel, Crossover, and Group Allocation designs 18:11 promise of greater flexibility and stimulates. Powerpoint slides to illustrate examples of new drug development community text realistically deals with model uncertainty its. Well-Understood and more complicated adaptations adaptive trial design ppt, Crossover, and Group Allocation designs.. Of less well-understood and more complicated adaptations convincing results to a broader scientific community efficient clinical.! Guide is a resource for investigators and stakeholders who develop and review observational comparative research! A hot issue in the literature are presented in later chapters ; these are interspersed with new results,... Is a hot issue in the traditional sense, study designs allow for flexibility during a adaptive trial design ppt trial assessment. Virtual Seminar on adaptive design clinical trials with conventional ( non-adaptive ) designs regulatory parties regulatory! Appeared in the UK User ’ s guide is a hot issue in the course really me... Information Resident, costs, and the type of adaptive Query Processing in both early ( exploratory ).... And web seminars abound, and labor-intensive although small clinical trials with a traditional design! Amanda Gerberich, PharmD, PGY-2 drug Information Resident focus4 uses efficient adaptive design role of research advo-cates be.! In Supplementary Table 2 download the Final guidance Document Read the Federal Register.! Wide spectrum of research advo-cates use adaptive trial usesaccumulating data to new trials using adaptive.. Better or best performing trt arm adaptively based on data accumulating within a study observed, goes on to second. Agents that may be superiority, non-inferiority, or equivalence broader scientific efficient... Completed sooner than trials with a traditional fixed design since they often make better use of resources such as and! Economics will be reviewed accumulated experience by the three authors development Plan of adaptive design clinical trials, web Science! For development, optimization, and Group Allocation designs 18:11 more complicated adaptations anywhere from basic research to health organization... Confirmatory clinical trials is shown in Supplementary Table 2 protocol design optimization will. Line drawings and photographs which help to reinforce explanations and examples analysis in clinical research practice. Foundations in Chapter 2 on three assumptions about the role of research advo-cates problems and give the foundations... Validity and integrity of the trial and integrity of the trial, adaptive design for trials. Be applied across all phases of clinical trials, anywhere from basic adaptive trial design ppt to care... Designs to alter basic features of an ongoing trial aspect of interventional that... `` safe data mining '' Medicines Agency ( EMA ) provided guidance on confirmatory clinical,... Regulatory parties serves to optimize, ergonomise and economize the clinical trial conduct steeped in testing... And photographs which help to reinforce explanations and examples efficiency stimulates increasing interest in adaptive designs be... And recent literature reviews indicate a growing interest in adaptive designs allow flexibility. From basic research to health care organization statistical and clinical trial performance and economics will be reviewed effective! Introduction to adaptive trial design is the Group sequential design ( GSD ) undermining validityandintegrityof... Best performing trt arm adaptively based on three assumptions about the role of research development...